Free Web Hosting Provider - Web Hosting - E-commerce - High Speed Internet - Free Web Page
Search the Web

The Banquo Legacy cover

Doctor Who

The Banquo Legacy

by Andy Lane and Justin Richards

Description :

The Eighth Doctor, on the run from the Time Lords, finds himself unable to regenerate and stuck in the late 19th century. Somewhere, a Time Lord agent is behind this. The Doctor must find a way to escape, but finds himself also caught up in an experiment that goes badly wrong.

Review :

Since SPOILER happened to Compassion, the Eight Doctor range of books have had the opportunity for some very interesting developement of her character. Unfortunately, she is virtually written out of the action for most of the story.

The story opens with a sinister murder. It's a bit of a distraction - I was hoping for an explaination of the strange behaviour of the girl, even a reappearance. It's a bit gruesome; the Doctor Who range of books definitely isn't aimed at children anymore. This can be good, since this story simply wouldn't be as good if it had to be acceptable for younger children, but when a book like Interference or The Ancestor Cell comes along, I wish that they could get back closer to the series roots. Interference has some good ideas, but was spoilt for me by all the violence, swearing and so on. I just don't want to read it. The Ancestor Cell doesn't even have the good ideas.

One of the striking aspects of the story is the way in which it is told from two different points of view, that of a Police Inspector, and that of a solicitor. I especially enjoyed this when conversations were told from the two angles. Because of this method, a lot of things regarding Fitz and the Doctor are implied to the reader. Also, both the accounts contain the Doctor's scientific speak in uncanny accuracy.

The story is enjoyable, and interesting. It's probably one of the best books I've read in the Eight Doctor range so far. The plot isn't entirely original, but it's well told. There are a few pointers as to what is yet to happen - such as the Doctor saying if he had to be stranded in one time, it would be around the time they are in. It leads into the Ancestor Cell, which sadly doesn't keep up the high standard.

Rating :

Four Stars (Out of Five)

Notes :

One of the original series of books featuring the Eight Doctor, Fitz and Compassion.

The review of the next book in the series, The Ancestor Cell, can be found here.


Home    Top
Last updated 11-Apr-01 by Caleb Woodbridge

Click Here!